The “Who Started It” Trap: How to Stop Keeping Score in Your Relationship

by | Oct 31, 2026

By Kiddada Asmara Grey and Zach Miers | He Said, She Said

You talked it out on Tuesday. You apologized. You both went to bed feeling better. Then Friday comes, a new argument starts, and there it is again: Tuesday, back on the table as evidence.

Every couple knows this one. Here’s how it looks from both sides.

He Said: Zach Miers

For a lot of men, scorekeeping feels like a goalpost that keeps moving. You fix something, you think it’s done, and then it comes back in a different fight with interest. After that happens enough times, a man learns something dangerous: apologizing doesn’t close anything. It just hands her ammunition.

So he stops apologizing. Not because he doesn’t care, but because it stopped feeling safe to admit he was wrong.

She Said: Kiddada Asmara Grey

Here’s what I want men to hear. When a woman brings up the past, it’s rarely to attack you. It’s because the hurt never actually closed. An apology without changed behavior leaves the account open. She heard “I’m sorry,” but then the same thing happened again, so in her mind, it was never really settled.

She isn’t keeping score to win. She’s keeping receipts because she’s still waiting for the change.

Where We Meet in the Middle

One fight, one topic. Talk only about what’s right in front of you. If something from the past is still sitting heavy, don’t sneak it into tonight’s argument. Set a separate time, when you’re both calm, to talk about that one thing on its own.

And when you apologize, back it up. “I’m sorry” plus a real change is what actually closes the account. Without the change, it’s just a pause between rounds.

Keep Having the Same Fight?

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More from Life Coaching Today